From: xanga@xanga.com
Subject: YOUR NEW HOUSE
Date: May 4, 2006 2:50:19 PM PDT
Reply-To: Al Jones
Al Jones has sent you this message!
------------------------------------------------------------
I saw your house. I can say without hesitation it is incredible. My partner, Ron Jones, and I are doing a small job down the street. Met the framers over there and I must say they are friendly and good at what they do; got their cards.
However, I have a question for you. Why would you put so much money in so much house in that neighborhood? I am from L.A. and I know that your new neighborhood is not the neighborhood most residents of L.A. would choose if they had a choice. You have clearly overbuilt for the area at any rate, so I can only imagine that you intend to reside their until our maker calls you. But, I am mystified by your choice of location for your new home; it is evident that you could have afforded to construct this ecologically balanced structure in a neighborhood with more desirable attributes. I am an African-American, with a diverse ancestry, and I know you are not, African-American, that is. So, why?
I can only imagine those people in that neighborhood attempting to get as much from you as possible, the material much, not spirtual much. I don't think you will save their souls by letting them see how much you have and comparing it to how little they have. Most of these people feel sorry for themselves and are angry at the world and this show of material wealth right in their backyard won't do much to diminish their lack of self-esteem or instill character.
I can only say you are brave, and from what I have learned a good man. i think you would have done better ministering during the day and leaving after dark; or in the alternative to have reduced your project by half. You have my admiration, and good luck on 37th Drive, you will need it.
AL JONES
Thank you, Al-- for your good wishes, and even more for your honesty in raising these issues with me. I respect a man who says what he thinks and says it graciously but to the point, as you have.
In a few short paragraphs you have hit on many issues with which my wife and I have wrestled for almost two decades. I'll respond just to the first one now, but I hope to respond to the others in the weeks to come, as time permits.
1. Why would you put so much money in so much house in that neighborhood? ...You have clearly overbuilt for the area... I can only imagine that you intend to reside their until our maker calls you.
Good guess: we never intended to build then sell in a few years and make a profit. We hope to raise our kids and grow old and grey in this home.
But there is more to it than that. Financial profit is not our concern, with this home: spiritual profit, social profit, relational profit, those are what we kept in mind as we designed and as we build.
And you bring up an interesting issue with this question: is it wrong to put "so much money" into a house in a poor neighborhood? Set the resale value aside for now and consider another implication: is there a moral mandate to build a small, poor house in a low-income neighborhood? Or, is there a moral mandate to build a home that is as small as possible, as modest as possible, to just meet one's need for shelter?
A legitimate case might be made for each of these. Obviously I disagree with them.
I see no intrinsic merit in a neighborhood like Bel Air which permits dream homes, versus some sort of curse overshadowing a neighborhood like Watts which requires all homes to be small, cheaply built and uninspiring. Bel Air homes are big and beautiful because such a home will sell well there. Watts housing tends to be small and plain because of those same market forces... and because those who know that neighborhood and can afford to build something different in Watts (or South Central or the Jungle or wherever) lack the inspiration to do so.
Instead they move to the Bel Airs of the world.
That second moral mandate actually appeals to me: it is a permaculture-ish Sarah Susanka mindset. I think Dan Price takes it to its logical extreme, and more power to him for doing so. Let's not spend our money building bigger houses & filling them with more stuff-- let's make the world a better place.
Soon we discover "the world" is awfully big. So big that it becomes an abstract concept. We can't do anything, individually, to improve "the world"-- we're too small, we don't have that kind of power. But we can do something to improve the part of the world where we choose to live.
For reasons I might explain later, my wife and I choose to live in South Central Los Angeles. And we do feel a moral mandate to use what we have and who we are as wisely and effectively as possible to make the world a better place, in the places where we connect with it.
** Who we are: We spent most of our first 15 years in the inner city hiding the fact that we are well-educated and relatively wealthy. (One of these qualities we work hard at, the other was a happy accident. You guess which is which.) We are no longer hiding these truths about ourselves. Sure enough, life in the 'hood is harder because of it. But at least we are being honest about who we are.
** What we have: An inheritance, one I tried to ignore for years. I didn't want to be "rich", to have one more thing (besides my skin color, culture, etc.) separating me from the folks in the 'hood I had come to know and love. Ignoring it was convenient, but bad stewardship. Far better to invest that inheritance in creating a home big enough to welcome guests, host events and parties, offer families a place to stay while they get back on their feet... you can't do that in a hobbit home. But you can do it in an ecologically wise way, another way we are doing our small part to make the world a better place.
(I am also hoping to use that inheritance to create a business that will serve needs and provide jobs at the same time, but after this house takes its share, there's not a whole lot left! But that's a topic for another day...)
If you were white, well-educated, and had a decent sum of money laid up for yourself, where would you live? In what would you invest your money, and your life? How would you raise your kids?
...and why?































Recent Comments